Sponsored By

Clarifying My Claim Of Being A Dairy BigotClarifying My Claim Of Being A Dairy Bigot

A lot of people wrote last week to chastise me for being too quick to jump on the dairy industry following the recent video revelations of abuse on an Ohio dairy. Some wrote to defend the dairy industry and its animal-care record; they made the point that

Troy Marshall 2

June 3, 2010

2 Min Read
Clarifying My Claim Of Being A Dairy Bigot

A lot of people wrote last week to chastise me for being too quick to jump on the dairy industry following the recent video revelations of abuse on an Ohio dairy. Some wrote to defend the dairy industry and its animal-care record; they made the point that – given the past history of the activist group that released the video – the odds were fairly high that the footage was totally contrived.

Sometimes, in an effort to be concise, I leave out a lot of things. I certainly understand that the dairy industry as a whole does a good job from an animal welfare, food safety and management standpoint. I also fully recognize that the video made no sense and seemed to be contrived at best, if not fully faked. It simply makes no sense that anyone would behave in such a despicable way.

My point wasn’t that this type of thing is widespread, but however rare and contrived these things are, they’ve happened all too frequently. My bigotry is based on this fact. It boils down to my belief that there’s a fundamental disconnect between the dairy and beef industries that requires the dairy industry to be far more vigilant than it has been in some respects.

The beef industry suffers from a similar disconnect in other areas. For instance, to ranchers, beef is the fundamental focus; after all, it’s the primary product. But beef is essentially a byproduct for the dairy industry. The truth is you don’t see these problems occurring in the milk-production phase of the dairy industry; it’s usually when the animals have entered the beef production – or byproduct – side of things.

I understand these videos aren’t accurate depictions, and that such videos are often staged or so distorted that they have little basis in reality. My point is that it doesn’t matter, as they do real and significant damage to our industry every time they happen. Regardless of the circumstances, the dairy industry must be far more vigilant in preventing these types of circumstances from occurring. Just embracing the fact that you will be misrepresented at any opportunity is perhaps the most important step.

My bigotry has nothing to do with facts – bigotry rarely does. I’m just saying the dairy industry must act decisively to prevent this trend from continuing.

About the Author(s)

Troy Marshall 2

BEEF Contributing Editor

Troy Marshall is a multi-generational rancher who grew up in Wheatland, WY, and obtained an Equine Science/Animal Science degree from Colorado State University where he competed on both the livestock and World Champion Horse Judging teams. Following college, he worked as a market analyst for Cattle-Fax covering different regions of the country. Troy also worked as director of commercial marketing for two breed associations; these positions were some of the first to provide direct links tying breed associations to the commercial cow-calf industry.

A visionary with a great grasp for all segments of the industry, Troy is a regular opinion contributor to BEEF Cow-Calf Weekly. His columns are widely reprinted and provide in-depth reporting and commentary from the perspective of a producer who truly understands the economics and challenges of the different industry segments. He is also a partner/owner in Allied Genetic Resources, a company created to change the definition of customer service provided by the seedstock industry. Troy and his wife Lorna have three children. 

Subscribe to Our Newsletters
BEEF Magazine is the source for beef production, management and market news.

You May Also Like